Ethereum Identify Service’s lead developer Nick Johnson took to social media to name out Unstoppable Domains on Thursday.
Johnson penned a collection of posts on X not solely criticizing Unstoppable Domains for the dearth of authorized backing or binding behind its Web3 Area Alliance group — which it each based and runs — but additionally accused Unstoppable of patenting an innovation allegedly made by ENS.
Johnson claims that ENS and Unstoppable Domains tried to debate the state of affairs exterior of the social media platform, however “failed” to make headway.
He claims that ENS, in distinction to Unstoppable, “haven’t pursued patents on our work.”
The problem at hand could be traced again to January when Unstoppable was granted a patent — Resolving Blockchain Domains — primarily based on “improvements that ENS developed and accommodates no novel improvements of its personal,” in accordance with Johnson.
Learn extra: What’s Ethereum Identify Service?
“It’s unattainable for any group to depend on such a nonbinding pledge when it issues core facets of its enterprise operations. We’re thus requesting that Unstoppable Domains put authorized weight behind its PR dedication, with an unconditional and irrevocable patent pledge,” Johnson continued.
If the 2 stay at odds on the problem, then ENS “stands able to problem this patent.”
Johnson additionally included screenshots of alleged communication between Unstoppable and ENS.
Based on the publish, Unstoppable responded to the preliminary ENS letter about patents to which Unstoppable mentioned that the pledge proposed by ENS just isn’t “needed.”
Unstoppable did, nevertheless, agree to interact in a “constructive dialogue” however pushed for them to interact in it inside the Web3 Area Alliance as a substitute of instantly between the 2 disputing events.
In response to Johnson’s open letter, Unstoppable founder Matthew Gould reiterated the open invite to affix the Alliance, although Johnson mentioned that the problem was that the patent was not being licensed overtly.
“There aren’t any ahead ensures that may be made that make sense given the altering panorama of the business. IMO the one answer is to extend collaboration and dialogue,” Gould responded.
“We are going to maintain the door open,” Gould mentioned in a ultimate publish.
Again in July, Unstoppable Domains mentioned it was trying to increase the Web3 neighborhood by integrating ENS domains and never marking them up.
The 2 have been rivals prior to now, and the transfer was not made as a part of a collaboration between the 2, as clarified to Blockworks this summer season.
